The reasons why guantanamo bay should remain open

The back story to that column was that " Democrats. Now some people suggesting such links might indeed be "wingnuts", and some of those might even be anti-Semites, but neither suggestion, neither the entirely plausible second suggestion or the implausible but hardly unthinkable first one, is remotely anti-Semitic by itself.

The reasons why guantanamo bay should remain open

Asker's rating Because there are no good alternatives to Gitmo. There are three types of prisoners in Gitmo.


The first are prisoners who stand accused of federal crimes. These prisoners will eventually be tried in federal or military courts. If convicted, they will go to a regular prison. If found innocent of the charges, they will be freed. If they are convicted, they will be imprisoned in a federal or military prison -- and often military prisons double as federal prisons -- in the United States.

The second set of prisoners are those who are not dangerous but, for a lack of better words, were in the wrong place at the wrong time.

They made a mistake and joined a group that was fighting the US in Afghanistan.

The reasons why guantanamo bay should remain open

They are not dangerous, not likely to rejoin the fight, so we can release them. The third set of prisoners are those who have not committed a federal crime, but are dangerous enemy combatants. And, if we release these prisoners, they will return to their organizations and continue to carry out war against the United States.

These prisoners are sometimes difficult to differentiate from the second group, and we don't want to make a mistake and release someone from this third group thinking he is someone who belongs to the second group.

Unlike those who will be tried, these prisoners will never go to trial. But, they can not be released until the conflict is over because they are active combatants.

We might end up having to hold this third set of prisoners for life. We could hold this this third group in the United States. There is little threat of this group escaping custody and remaining free for long. However, NIMBYs Not in my backyard are afraid that a facility holding this third group will make their communities more likely to be attacked by Muslim terrorists.

And so when the government has tried to locate a prison in the United States, it has come against local opposition. Further, until we get a place that can house these prisoners, such as the prison under consideration in Illinois, Gitmo has to remain open.

Thus, they are people who say, "Build it, but not in my backyard or community.I went to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba (GTMO) with no expectations, no preconceived notions and an open mind. Of course, I had heard all the criticisms, opinions, and negative media coverage but as always, I wanted to see it for myself and form my own opinion.

So after five days on the Guantanamo Bay Naval. Jan 07,  · Why should Guantanamo bay stay open? why should Guantanamo bay stay open. Follow. 12 answers Report Abuse. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Oh and reasons why guantanamo bay should stay opened?

So im debating why Guantanamo bay should stay open and i need some help? Answer Resolved. Thanks to Before I begin, I would like to say that theorizing about what happened on 9/11, when you’re not being given answers to your questions about that day by the people who SHOULD be able to do so, is PERFECTLY normal.

As is suspecting that the reason these answers aren’t being given is “sinister” in nature. Looks like I get the first post again. Hope no one thinks I’m working some dark magic.

Just a product of having no life I’m afraid. Having read Nathan Robinson’s article previously, I came to the conclusion that it was saying “You can’t argue against white supremacists”. Get up to the minute breaking political news and in-depth analysis on The Guantanamo Bay detention camp is a United States military prison located within Guantanamo Bay Naval Base, also referred to as Guantánamo or GTMO (/ ˈ ɡ ɪ t m oʊ /), which is on the coast of Guantánamo Bay in Cuba.

Since the inmates have been detained indefinitely without trial and several detainees have allegedly been tortured, the .

News: latest stories, exclusives, opinion & analysis - Mirror Online